Alpha Matting Evaluation Website

Image Matting Evaluation•Datasets•Code•Submit

How to use this page?

Please be patient until all images have loaded completely.
Move the mouse over the numbers in the table to see the corresponding images.
Drag the red rectangle in the leftmost image to change the location of the zoom.
Press and hold any key to temporarily deactivate the links.

Image matting evaluation results Competition: Low resolution High resolution
Error type: SAD MSE Gradient Connectivity

Sum of Absolute Differences overall
avg.
small avg.
large avg.
user Troll
(Strongly Transparent)
Input Doll
(Strongly Transparent)
Input Donkey
(Medium Transparent)
Input Elephant
(Medium Transparent)
Input Plant
(Little Transparent)
Input Pineapple
(Little Transparent)
Input Plastic bag
(Highly Transparent)
Input Net
(Highly Transparent)
Input

rank rank rank rank small large user small large user small large user small large user small large user small large user small large user small large user

SampleNet Matting 3.5 2.5 2.8 5.3 9.1 1 9.7 1 9.8 2 4.3 1 4.8 1 5.1 1 3.4 4 3.7 4 3.2 6 0.9 1 1.1 2 2 3 5.1 1 6.8 2 9.7 8 2.5 2 4 3 3.7 1 18.6 5 19.3 5 19.1 10 20 5 21.6 4 23.2 11

FE2E High-Quality Matting 4.2 3.9 4.1 4.6 10.1 3 11.1 3 9.3 1 5.5 8 6.4 6 6.9 8 3.4 3 3.7 3 3.2 5 1 3 1.7 4 1.9 1 5.7 8 7.8 8 11 13 2.5 1 3.8 2 3.8 2 17.3 2 18.4 2 17.4 6 19.6 3 21.8 5 20.2 1

Deep Matting 5.3 6.5 4.3 5.3 10.7 5 11.2 5 11 4 4.8 3 5.8 5 5.6 3 2.8 1 2.9 1 2.9 1 1.1 4 1.1 1 2 4 6 17 7.1 4 8.9 4 2.7 3 3.2 1 3.9 3 19.2 6 19.6 7 18.7 7 21.8 13 23.9 10 24.1 16

Information-flow matting 6.1 7.4 5.8 5.3 10.3 4 11.2 4 12.5 6 5.6 12 7.3 10 7.3 10 3.8 5 4.1 6 3 3 1.4 7 2.3 6 2 6 5.9 14 7.1 5 8.6 2 3.6 6 5.7 5 4.6 7 18.3 4 19.3 4 15.8 2 20.2 7 22.2 6 22.3 6

Superpixel-affinity matting 7 6.9 7.3 6.9 12.2 18 18.6 20 14.7 14 5 5 5.3 3 6.4 5 3.9 7 4 5 3 2 1.4 6 2.4 7 1.9 2 5.2 2 6.4 1 8.5 1 3.6 5 6.4 7 4.6 6 21.2 11 22.5 14 20.4 15 19.3 1 19.1 1 22.9 10

DCNN Matting 7.6 9.5 5.6 7.6 12 15 14.1 8 14.5 12 5.3 6 6.4 7 6.8 7 3.9 8 4.5 8 3.4 8 1.6 13 2.5 8 2.2 9 6 16 6.9 3 9.1 5 4 9 6 6 5.3 9 19.9 7 19.2 3 19.1 9 19.4 2 20 2 21.2 2

AlphaGAN 8.7 9.5 8.4 8.1 9.6 2 10.7 2 10.4 3 4.7 2 5.3 2 5.4 2 3.1 2 3.7 2 3.1 4 1.1 5 1.3 3 2 5 6.4 22 8.3 15 9.3 6 3.6 4 5 4 4.3 4 20.8 8 21.5 9 20.6 16 25.7 31 28.7 30 26.7 25

Three-layer graph matting 12.5 9.1 9.9 18.5 10.7 6 15.2 9 13.8 9 4.9 4 5.6 4 8.1 22 3.9 6 4.4 7 3.6 11 1 2 1.8 5 3 23 5.9 12 7.3 7 12.4 23 4.2 12 8 14 8.5 32 24.2 23 25.6 24 24.2 24 20.5 8 23.5 9 22.2 4

ATPM Matting 15.3 18.8 16.9 10.1 14 33 17.8 16 13.4 7 5.5 7 6.4 8 7.3 11 5.4 40 6.4 35 4.3 28 1.7 16 3.3 14 2.3 12 6.8 26 8 11 8.7 3 4.2 10 7.5 11 5.5 10 17.2 1 17.6 1 15.7 1 22.6 17 37.3 39 22.8 9

Three Stages Matting 15.5 15.4 15.5 15.6 11.7 14 13.9 7 13.9 10 5.6 9 7.4 12 7.9 16 4.6 20 5.5 21 4.2 22 2.2 29 4 21 3.1 28 6.5 23 11 33 11.9 18 4 7 6.5 8 4.5 5 23.3 17 23.2 19 22.3 19 19.6 4 20.8 3 22.4 7

CSC Matting 16.6 20.5 12.5 16.8 13.6 30 15.6 10 14.5 11 6.2 20 7.5 13 8.1 23 4.6 21 4.8 10 4.2 25 1.8 19 2.7 9 2.5 14 5.5 7 7.3 6 9.7 7 4.6 16 7.6 12 6.9 19 23.7 19 23 17 21 17 26.3 32 27.2 23 25.2 18

LNSP Matting 17.1 13.5 16.9 21 12.2 16 22.5 36 19.5 41 5.6 10 8.1 15 8.8 33 4.6 18 5.9 26 3.6 10 1.5 10 3.5 17 3.1 27 6.2 18 8.1 13 10.7 12 4 8 7.1 9 6.4 15 21.5 12 20.8 8 16.3 3 22.5 16 24.4 11 27.8 27

Graph-based sparse matting 17.8 18.4 18.4 16.8 12.6 22 20.5 28 14.8 18 5.7 14 7.3 9 6.4 6 4.5 16 5.3 17 3.7 12 1.4 9 3.3 15 2.3 11 6.3 20 7.9 9 11.1 14 4.2 11 8.3 17 6.4 14 28.7 36 31.3 37 27.1 33 23.6 19 25.1 15 27.3 26

Patch-based Matting 17.9 12.5 19.6 21.6 10.9 8 19 21 15.7 24 6 17 9.5 29 8.3 25 4.3 12 5.2 14 4.2 24 1.6 12 3.2 12 2.6 15 5.2 3 9 21 12.4 20 4.7 17 9.7 24 7 20 21.6 13 21.7 10 24.9 26 23.5 18 28.1 26 25.6 19

KL-Divergence Based Sparse Sampling 18.5 17.5 17.5 20.4 11.6 13 17.5 15 14.7 15 5.6 11 8.5 20 8 18 4.9 33 5.3 15 3.7 13 1.5 11 3.5 16 2.1 7 5.8 10 8.3 14 14.1 31 5.6 28 9.3 22 8 28 24.6 24 27.7 31 28.9 36 20.7 10 22.7 7 23.9 15

TSPS-RV Matting 19.5 18.1 18.6 21.6 11.3 12 16.4 13 13.7 8 6.1 18 8.1 17 8.6 30 4.5 14 5.4 19 4.1 21 1.4 8 3.3 13 3.5 37 7.9 36 8.9 19 12.4 22 6.2 32 9 20 8.7 34 22.8 16 23.5 20 21.4 18 20.7 9 28.5 28 22.2 3

Iterative Transductive Matting 20.3 21.8 20 19.3 13.1 27 17.2 14 15.6 23 5.7 13 8.6 22 7.8 15 5.1 36 5.5 20 3.9 14 1.9 20 5.8 33 2.6 16 6.6 24 8.5 17 13.8 30 5.4 22 10 25 7.4 25 25.5 26 24 21 23.8 23 20.1 6 22.7 8 22.7 8

Comprehensive sampling 20.5 17.8 20.4 23.4 11.2 11 18.5 19 14.8 16 6.5 26 9.5 28 8.9 35 4.5 15 4.9 11 4.1 20 1.7 15 3.1 11 2.3 13 5.4 6 9.8 25 13.4 28 5.5 26 11.5 32 7.4 27 23.9 21 22 12 22.8 20 23.8 22 28 25 28.1 28

SVR Matting 20.5 23.4 20.5 17.8 18.7 45 30.7 47 19.1 38 6.8 32 7.7 14 7.6 14 4.7 27 5 13 3.4 7 1.9 21 4.7 25 2.9 21 5.8 9 8.7 18 10.5 9 4.3 13 8 15 5.6 12 21.2 10 22.1 13 17.1 5 25.6 30 26.1 19 30.6 36

Comprehensive Weighted Color and Texture 21 21 21.8 20.3 14.6 34 16 11 15.7 25 6.8 31 10 32 7.9 17 4.3 11 5 12 4.1 18 1.7 14 3.5 18 2.2 8 5.4 5 9.9 27 12.8 26 4.3 14 7.4 10 5.2 8 28.3 35 28.1 32 25.4 29 24 24 30.2 32 28.7 31

Sparse coded matting 21.5 25 22.1 17.4 13.7 31 25.8 43 14.8 19 6.4 23 8.2 18 6.2 4 4.7 22 5.4 18 4 16 1.8 18 3.1 10 2.3 10 5.9 13 8 12 10.6 10 4.5 15 8 13 5.5 11 30.3 39 33.1 41 29.2 37 27.7 39 27.2 22 29 32

LocalSamplingAndKnnClassification 22.9 25.6 20.8 22.4 12.6 21 16 12 12.4 5 5.8 15 8.1 16 8 19 4.5 17 5.5 22 4.1 17 2.2 30 5.1 28 3.4 35 8.1 37 10.5 29 15.6 36 7.3 36 12.3 35 9.4 35 24.1 22 21.8 11 19.7 11 24.7 27 24.8 13 25.9 21

Weighted Color and Texture Matting 23.5 21.3 25.5 23.9 13.1 28 17.8 17 15.8 26 6.5 25 9.4 26 8.6 29 4.2 10 4.7 9 3.9 15 1.7 17 6 34 2.7 17 6.4 21 11 32 16.3 37 4.8 18 9.1 21 6.5 16 23.7 18 24.8 23 23.2 21 26.5 33 40.2 42 28.5 30

CCM 23.8 27 23.5 20.9 13.8 32 20.8 29 16.9 34 6.4 24 8.9 24 8.2 24 4.7 23 5.9 27 3.6 9 2.5 34 4.3 22 3 22 7 28 9 20 10.6 11 4.9 19 8.1 16 5.7 13 25.6 27 27.5 30 24.5 25 25.4 29 26.4 20 28.2 29

Shared Matting 24.2 22.4 27.9 22.4 10.8 7 20.5 27 15 20 7.8 38 11.6 39 8.1 20 4.2 9 5.3 16 4.2 23 2.1 23 5.8 32 2.9 20 5.9 15 9.2 22 11.4 16 5 20 8.8 18 6.8 18 34.9 44 34.9 42 34.3 42 23.9 23 28.4 27 25.7 20

LNCLM matting 24.3 26.9 24 22 10.9 9 11.2 6 16.7 32 6.9 34 8.9 25 7.2 9 5.6 42 7 43 4.1 19 2.5 36 5.1 29 3.5 38 7.5 31 10 28 12 19 5.5 27 11.3 29 7.3 24 25.2 25 23 18 19.9 13 21.2 11 25 14 26.4 22

PDMS 25.9 25.4 26.6 25.6 12.9 26 19.3 22 14.6 13 6.2 21 10.2 34 8.5 27 4.8 31 6.1 30 4.2 26 2.1 25 4.4 23 3.1 26 5.3 4 8.3 16 11.7 17 5.5 24 11 28 7.1 23 29.6 37 32.2 39 31.6 40 26.8 35 27.1 21 29.1 33

Global Sampling Matting 27 23.6 29.5 27.9 10.9 10 22.7 37 15.4 21 6.3 22 9.5 30 9 36 4.7 24 6.4 37 4.3 30 2.2 31 5.6 31 3.4 34 6.9 27 9.6 24 12.9 27 6.3 33 12.5 36 8.6 33 25.8 28 27.5 29 25.3 28 22 14 24.4 12 23.7 14

SRLO Matting 27.8 26.6 29.9 27 14.7 35 18 18 17.7 36 6.9 33 10.7 35 8.9 34 4.9 34 5.7 24 4.7 38 2.1 26 6.5 35 2.8 19 6.3 19 10.9 31 15.2 35 5.4 21 11.6 33 7 22 26.5 33 29.7 34 25.1 27 21.7 12 28.5 29 22.3 5

Segmentation-based matting 27.9 28.8 26.9 28.1 12.8 25 23.5 39 16.6 31 6.6 27 8.3 19 7.3 12 4.8 32 6.1 31 4.3 31 2.1 24 3.9 20 3.1 25 6.7 25 8 10 13.4 29 6 31 8.8 19 8.2 29 31.6 40 35.6 43 38.8 44 24.5 26 32 34 26.7 24

Improved color matting 29 29.1 28.3 29.8 14.9 36 24.5 41 20 42 6.7 29 9.5 27 8.5 28 4.6 19 6.1 32 4.3 32 2.6 38 5.4 30 3.4 36 7.5 32 9.9 26 12.5 24 6 29 10.1 26 8.4 31 26.1 29 26.7 28 23.6 22 23.8 21 25.6 16 26.7 23

Local Spline Regression (LSR) 29.5 31.8 26 30.6 12.2 17 20 25 16.2 27 6.1 19 8.8 23 8.1 21 5.2 38 6.2 34 4.6 35 2.2 32 4.9 27 3.1 29 9.4 42 11.9 36 18.3 40 8.2 39 11.4 30 10.1 37 26.4 31 22.5 15 20.2 14 27 36 26 18 39.8 42

KNN Matting 29.8 31.9 31.3 26.3 16.2 40 19.7 23 16.8 33 8 39 11 36 9 38 4.7 25 6.7 40 4.3 27 3 41 7.7 41 3.7 39 9.2 40 11.3 34 11.3 15 6 30 10.4 27 6.7 17 18.1 3 19.6 6 17 4 27.4 37 41 43 32.7 37

Global Sampling Matting (filter version) 30 27.8 32.4 29.9 12.3 19 24.3 40 16.3 28 7.3 36 10.2 33 9.5 39 5.1 37 6.4 36 4.7 39 2.4 33 4.7 26 3.2 31 5.9 11 9.5 23 12.4 21 6.5 34 13.1 37 8.3 30 26.5 32 28.3 33 30 39 23.6 20 29.1 31 23.5 12

Learning Based Matting 30.8 31.4 29.9 31.1 16 39 22 35 18.7 37 6.6 28 7.4 11 7.4 13 4.8 29 6.1 29 4.3 33 2.1 22 3.7 19 2.8 18 7.5 33 14.5 42 19.5 43 8.6 43 14.1 40 14.6 45 22.5 14 24.8 22 19.9 12 34.6 43 38.5 41 51.2 48

LMSPIR 32 31 33.6 31.5 15.2 38 20 24 19.1 39 6.7 30 11.2 37 8.7 32 4.8 30 5.8 25 4.6 37 2.1 27 6.8 38 3 24 7.9 35 14.3 41 20.2 44 5.5 25 11.4 31 7 21 29.7 38 31 36 29.6 38 24 25 34.2 37 25 17

Shared Matting (Real Time) 32.4 31 33.3 33 12.4 20 21.6 31 16.3 29 9.5 42 13.5 41 9.9 40 4.4 13 5.6 23 4.4 34 2.5 37 6.8 39 3.2 32 7.1 29 10.8 30 12.6 25 5.4 23 9.7 23 7.4 26 35.5 46 35.8 44 35.5 43 27.6 38 33.4 35 29.8 35

Closed-Form Matting 32.8 31.4 30.4 36.8 12.7 23 21.9 34 17.2 35 5.9 16 8.5 21 8.6 31 4.7 26 6 28 4.3 29 2.2 28 4.6 24 3.3 33 9.3 41 12.1 37 19.3 42 8.3 40 14.9 42 13.4 44 34.2 43 32.4 40 27.4 34 26.5 34 25.7 17 48.3 46

Improving Sampling Criterion 36.8 35.8 38.4 36.3 12.7 24 21.1 30 16.4 30 11.5 45 17 46 12.1 45 5.8 44 8.1 46 5.7 44 5.4 49 12.1 48 6.6 48 9.6 44 15.7 43 17.8 38 10.2 45 17 43 11.2 42 23.8 20 26.7 27 25.9 30 22.2 15 27.3 24 23.7 13

Cell-based matting Laplacian 37.1 39.3 35.9 36.3 15.1 37 21.7 32 15.6 22 7.6 37 11.4 38 9 37 5.7 43 6.7 41 5.2 42 3.1 42 6.7 36 4.5 42 8.6 38 11.4 35 14.9 33 8.5 42 13.5 39 11.1 40 27.7 34 26.2 26 27.6 35 32.4 41 37.6 40 37.9 39

Large Kernel Matting 37.3 39.1 36.6 36.3 17.2 41 21.8 33 20.7 43 7.2 35 9.6 31 8.4 26 5.3 39 6.6 39 4.6 36 2.9 40 8.2 43 4.2 40 8.6 39 12.1 38 14.7 32 8 38 13.4 38 11.2 41 33 41 31.8 38 26.1 31 32.1 40 32 33 38.4 41

Robust Matting 38.1 34.3 39 41 17.3 42 28.4 45 21.1 44 10.1 43 16.9 45 11.4 43 4.8 28 6.5 38 5 41 2.8 39 7.3 40 4.4 41 7.3 30 14 40 18.1 39 6.8 35 14.6 41 10.6 39 22.7 15 26.1 25 32.1 41 34.4 42 37 38 38 40

SPS matting 40.1 39.4 43.1 37.8 13.4 29 23 38 14.8 17 12.5 46 18.5 47 12.4 46 6.6 48 9.4 49 6.5 49 4.5 47 12.7 49 5.4 45 9.5 43 16.4 45 18.6 41 9.8 44 18.1 46 10.6 38 26.1 30 30.9 35 26.2 32 25 28 33.5 36 29.5 34

High-res matting 41.2 39.8 42.5 41.4 18.6 44 25.8 42 24.6 46 8.6 40 14.1 42 11.1 42 5 35 6.2 33 4.8 40 2.5 35 8.3 44 3.2 30 7.8 34 14 39 21.4 45 8.5 41 18.1 47 12.2 43 35.3 45 38.1 46 42.6 47 38.7 44 54.6 47 36.8 38

Transfusive Weights 41.5 41.5 41.4 41.8 23.2 46 26.7 44 22.4 45 9.2 41 11.9 40 10.4 41 6.1 46 8.1 45 5.9 46 3.8 45 8 42 5.3 44 12.9 47 21.4 47 37.6 51 13.1 50 22.8 49 18.3 50 20.9 9 22.9 16 19 8 59.5 48 65.7 48 72.8 49

Random Walk Matting 44.9 46.5 42.5 45.8 17.9 43 20.3 26 19.4 40 11.3 44 15.6 43 11.8 44 5.8 45 7 42 6.3 48 3.4 43 6.7 37 4.6 43 13.1 49 22.1 48 27.4 47 12.3 49 18 45 15.7 48 44.1 50 43.5 49 41 46 75.1 49 81.8 50 80.6 50

Geodesic Matting 46.1 47 45.9 45.5 26.9 49 38.5 50 32.5 49 14.2 47 16.5 44 17.4 48 11.7 51 14 52 9.4 51 7.6 51 15.1 50 8.7 51 12.8 46 16.7 46 15.1 34 7.3 37 12.1 34 9.8 36 37.3 48 37.4 45 42.8 48 48.6 47 50 46 48.6 47

Iterative BP Matting 47.2 46.5 47.1 48 23.6 47 29.9 46 27.2 47 16.7 48 24.3 49 20.7 51 6.7 49 9 47 6.3 47 3.8 44 11.3 46 6.8 50 14.1 50 22.8 49 27.9 48 11.4 47 19 48 14.7 46 33.4 42 39.3 47 47.5 51 40.6 45 48.1 45 45.1 44

Easy Matting 47.6 48 47 47.9 23.9 48 32.6 48 30 48 17.1 49 21.8 48 19.4 50 6.3 47 7.5 44 5.8 45 4.7 48 10.5 45 5.6 46 12.1 45 15.7 44 22.9 46 11.2 46 17 44 14.8 47 49.5 51 49.6 51 46.2 50 77.8 50 108.6 52 109.2 51

Improved Bayesian 48.1 48 48.5 47.9 31.2 51 34.9 49 33.9 51 17.8 50 24.4 50 17.2 47 5.5 41 9.3 48 5.3 43 3.9 46 11.4 47 6.6 49 13 48 29.5 50 34.6 50 11.9 48 24.5 50 16.1 49 42.9 49 44.6 50 46 49 92.4 51 46.5 44 45.4 45

Bayesian Matting 49.4 49.5 50.4 48.3 30.3 50 42.4 51 33.4 50 19.2 51 25.8 51 18.4 49 10.8 50 12.4 50 10.8 52 6.6 50 18.5 52 6.2 47 14.2 51 29.8 51 33.2 49 15.4 51 30.6 51 19.7 51 35.8 47 40.6 48 39.6 45 45.3 46 76.8 49 43.6 43

Poisson Matting 51.8 52 51.6 51.8 51.8 52 56.2 52 52 52 28.3 52 43.5 52 30.7 52 12.1 52 13.7 51 9.2 50 11.7 52 18.4 51 11.2 52 22.4 52 36.8 52 55.5 52 21.4 52 32.2 52 22.7 52 53.6 52 72.9 52 58.4 52 125.5 52 84.8 51 139.7 52

Move the mouse over the numbers in the table to see the corresponding images.Click to compare with the ground truth. Press a key to deactivate the links (to better use the zoom).

Sum of Absolute Differences	overall	avg. small	avg. large	avg. user	Troll (Strongly Transparent) Input	Doll (Strongly Transparent) Input	Donkey (Medium Transparent) Input	Elephant (Medium Transparent) Input	Plant (Little Transparent) Input	Pineapple (Little Transparent) Input	Plastic bag (Highly Transparent) Input	Net (Highly Transparent) Input
SampleNet Matting	3.5	2.5	2.8	5.3	9.1 1	9.7 1	9.8 2	4.3 1	4.8 1	5.1 1	3.4 4	3.7 4	3.2 6	0.9 1	1.1 2	2 3	5.1 1	6.8 2	9.7 8	2.5 2	4 3	3.7 1	18.6 5	19.3 5	19.1 10	20 5	21.6 4	23.2 11
FE2E High-Quality Matting	4.2	3.9	4.1	4.6	10.1 3	11.1 3	9.3 1	5.5 8	6.4 6	6.9 8	3.4 3	3.7 3	3.2 5	1 3	1.7 4	1.9 1	5.7 8	7.8 8	11 13	2.5 1	3.8 2	3.8 2	17.3 2	18.4 2	17.4 6	19.6 3	21.8 5	20.2 1
Deep Matting	5.3	6.5	4.3	5.3	10.7 5	11.2 5	11 4	4.8 3	5.8 5	5.6 3	2.8 1	2.9 1	2.9 1	1.1 4	1.1 1	2 4	6 17	7.1 4	8.9 4	2.7 3	3.2 1	3.9 3	19.2 6	19.6 7	18.7 7	21.8 13	23.9 10	24.1 16
Information-flow matting	6.1	7.4	5.8	5.3	10.3 4	11.2 4	12.5 6	5.6 12	7.3 10	7.3 10	3.8 5	4.1 6	3 3	1.4 7	2.3 6	2 6	5.9 14	7.1 5	8.6 2	3.6 6	5.7 5	4.6 7	18.3 4	19.3 4	15.8 2	20.2 7	22.2 6	22.3 6
Superpixel-affinity matting	7	6.9	7.3	6.9	12.2 18	18.6 20	14.7 14	5 5	5.3 3	6.4 5	3.9 7	4 5	3 2	1.4 6	2.4 7	1.9 2	5.2 2	6.4 1	8.5 1	3.6 5	6.4 7	4.6 6	21.2 11	22.5 14	20.4 15	19.3 1	19.1 1	22.9 10
DCNN Matting	7.6	9.5	5.6	7.6	12 15	14.1 8	14.5 12	5.3 6	6.4 7	6.8 7	3.9 8	4.5 8	3.4 8	1.6 13	2.5 8	2.2 9	6 16	6.9 3	9.1 5	4 9	6 6	5.3 9	19.9 7	19.2 3	19.1 9	19.4 2	20 2	21.2 2
AlphaGAN	8.7	9.5	8.4	8.1	9.6 2	10.7 2	10.4 3	4.7 2	5.3 2	5.4 2	3.1 2	3.7 2	3.1 4	1.1 5	1.3 3	2 5	6.4 22	8.3 15	9.3 6	3.6 4	5 4	4.3 4	20.8 8	21.5 9	20.6 16	25.7 31	28.7 30	26.7 25
Three-layer graph matting	12.5	9.1	9.9	18.5	10.7 6	15.2 9	13.8 9	4.9 4	5.6 4	8.1 22	3.9 6	4.4 7	3.6 11	1 2	1.8 5	3 23	5.9 12	7.3 7	12.4 23	4.2 12	8 14	8.5 32	24.2 23	25.6 24	24.2 24	20.5 8	23.5 9	22.2 4
ATPM Matting	15.3	18.8	16.9	10.1	14 33	17.8 16	13.4 7	5.5 7	6.4 8	7.3 11	5.4 40	6.4 35	4.3 28	1.7 16	3.3 14	2.3 12	6.8 26	8 11	8.7 3	4.2 10	7.5 11	5.5 10	17.2 1	17.6 1	15.7 1	22.6 17	37.3 39	22.8 9
Three Stages Matting	15.5	15.4	15.5	15.6	11.7 14	13.9 7	13.9 10	5.6 9	7.4 12	7.9 16	4.6 20	5.5 21	4.2 22	2.2 29	4 21	3.1 28	6.5 23	11 33	11.9 18	4 7	6.5 8	4.5 5	23.3 17	23.2 19	22.3 19	19.6 4	20.8 3	22.4 7
CSC Matting	16.6	20.5	12.5	16.8	13.6 30	15.6 10	14.5 11	6.2 20	7.5 13	8.1 23	4.6 21	4.8 10	4.2 25	1.8 19	2.7 9	2.5 14	5.5 7	7.3 6	9.7 7	4.6 16	7.6 12	6.9 19	23.7 19	23 17	21 17	26.3 32	27.2 23	25.2 18
LNSP Matting	17.1	13.5	16.9	21	12.2 16	22.5 36	19.5 41	5.6 10	8.1 15	8.8 33	4.6 18	5.9 26	3.6 10	1.5 10	3.5 17	3.1 27	6.2 18	8.1 13	10.7 12	4 8	7.1 9	6.4 15	21.5 12	20.8 8	16.3 3	22.5 16	24.4 11	27.8 27
Graph-based sparse matting	17.8	18.4	18.4	16.8	12.6 22	20.5 28	14.8 18	5.7 14	7.3 9	6.4 6	4.5 16	5.3 17	3.7 12	1.4 9	3.3 15	2.3 11	6.3 20	7.9 9	11.1 14	4.2 11	8.3 17	6.4 14	28.7 36	31.3 37	27.1 33	23.6 19	25.1 15	27.3 26
Patch-based Matting	17.9	12.5	19.6	21.6	10.9 8	19 21	15.7 24	6 17	9.5 29	8.3 25	4.3 12	5.2 14	4.2 24	1.6 12	3.2 12	2.6 15	5.2 3	9 21	12.4 20	4.7 17	9.7 24	7 20	21.6 13	21.7 10	24.9 26	23.5 18	28.1 26	25.6 19
KL-Divergence Based Sparse Sampling	18.5	17.5	17.5	20.4	11.6 13	17.5 15	14.7 15	5.6 11	8.5 20	8 18	4.9 33	5.3 15	3.7 13	1.5 11	3.5 16	2.1 7	5.8 10	8.3 14	14.1 31	5.6 28	9.3 22	8 28	24.6 24	27.7 31	28.9 36	20.7 10	22.7 7	23.9 15
TSPS-RV Matting	19.5	18.1	18.6	21.6	11.3 12	16.4 13	13.7 8	6.1 18	8.1 17	8.6 30	4.5 14	5.4 19	4.1 21	1.4 8	3.3 13	3.5 37	7.9 36	8.9 19	12.4 22	6.2 32	9 20	8.7 34	22.8 16	23.5 20	21.4 18	20.7 9	28.5 28	22.2 3
Iterative Transductive Matting	20.3	21.8	20	19.3	13.1 27	17.2 14	15.6 23	5.7 13	8.6 22	7.8 15	5.1 36	5.5 20	3.9 14	1.9 20	5.8 33	2.6 16	6.6 24	8.5 17	13.8 30	5.4 22	10 25	7.4 25	25.5 26	24 21	23.8 23	20.1 6	22.7 8	22.7 8
Comprehensive sampling	20.5	17.8	20.4	23.4	11.2 11	18.5 19	14.8 16	6.5 26	9.5 28	8.9 35	4.5 15	4.9 11	4.1 20	1.7 15	3.1 11	2.3 13	5.4 6	9.8 25	13.4 28	5.5 26	11.5 32	7.4 27	23.9 21	22 12	22.8 20	23.8 22	28 25	28.1 28
SVR Matting	20.5	23.4	20.5	17.8	18.7 45	30.7 47	19.1 38	6.8 32	7.7 14	7.6 14	4.7 27	5 13	3.4 7	1.9 21	4.7 25	2.9 21	5.8 9	8.7 18	10.5 9	4.3 13	8 15	5.6 12	21.2 10	22.1 13	17.1 5	25.6 30	26.1 19	30.6 36
Comprehensive Weighted Color and Texture	21	21	21.8	20.3	14.6 34	16 11	15.7 25	6.8 31	10 32	7.9 17	4.3 11	5 12	4.1 18	1.7 14	3.5 18	2.2 8	5.4 5	9.9 27	12.8 26	4.3 14	7.4 10	5.2 8	28.3 35	28.1 32	25.4 29	24 24	30.2 32	28.7 31
Sparse coded matting	21.5	25	22.1	17.4	13.7 31	25.8 43	14.8 19	6.4 23	8.2 18	6.2 4	4.7 22	5.4 18	4 16	1.8 18	3.1 10	2.3 10	5.9 13	8 12	10.6 10	4.5 15	8 13	5.5 11	30.3 39	33.1 41	29.2 37	27.7 39	27.2 22	29 32
LocalSamplingAndKnnClassification	22.9	25.6	20.8	22.4	12.6 21	16 12	12.4 5	5.8 15	8.1 16	8 19	4.5 17	5.5 22	4.1 17	2.2 30	5.1 28	3.4 35	8.1 37	10.5 29	15.6 36	7.3 36	12.3 35	9.4 35	24.1 22	21.8 11	19.7 11	24.7 27	24.8 13	25.9 21
Weighted Color and Texture Matting	23.5	21.3	25.5	23.9	13.1 28	17.8 17	15.8 26	6.5 25	9.4 26	8.6 29	4.2 10	4.7 9	3.9 15	1.7 17	6 34	2.7 17	6.4 21	11 32	16.3 37	4.8 18	9.1 21	6.5 16	23.7 18	24.8 23	23.2 21	26.5 33	40.2 42	28.5 30
CCM	23.8	27	23.5	20.9	13.8 32	20.8 29	16.9 34	6.4 24	8.9 24	8.2 24	4.7 23	5.9 27	3.6 9	2.5 34	4.3 22	3 22	7 28	9 20	10.6 11	4.9 19	8.1 16	5.7 13	25.6 27	27.5 30	24.5 25	25.4 29	26.4 20	28.2 29
Shared Matting	24.2	22.4	27.9	22.4	10.8 7	20.5 27	15 20	7.8 38	11.6 39	8.1 20	4.2 9	5.3 16	4.2 23	2.1 23	5.8 32	2.9 20	5.9 15	9.2 22	11.4 16	5 20	8.8 18	6.8 18	34.9 44	34.9 42	34.3 42	23.9 23	28.4 27	25.7 20
LNCLM matting	24.3	26.9	24	22	10.9 9	11.2 6	16.7 32	6.9 34	8.9 25	7.2 9	5.6 42	7 43	4.1 19	2.5 36	5.1 29	3.5 38	7.5 31	10 28	12 19	5.5 27	11.3 29	7.3 24	25.2 25	23 18	19.9 13	21.2 11	25 14	26.4 22
PDMS	25.9	25.4	26.6	25.6	12.9 26	19.3 22	14.6 13	6.2 21	10.2 34	8.5 27	4.8 31	6.1 30	4.2 26	2.1 25	4.4 23	3.1 26	5.3 4	8.3 16	11.7 17	5.5 24	11 28	7.1 23	29.6 37	32.2 39	31.6 40	26.8 35	27.1 21	29.1 33
Global Sampling Matting	27	23.6	29.5	27.9	10.9 10	22.7 37	15.4 21	6.3 22	9.5 30	9 36	4.7 24	6.4 37	4.3 30	2.2 31	5.6 31	3.4 34	6.9 27	9.6 24	12.9 27	6.3 33	12.5 36	8.6 33	25.8 28	27.5 29	25.3 28	22 14	24.4 12	23.7 14
SRLO Matting	27.8	26.6	29.9	27	14.7 35	18 18	17.7 36	6.9 33	10.7 35	8.9 34	4.9 34	5.7 24	4.7 38	2.1 26	6.5 35	2.8 19	6.3 19	10.9 31	15.2 35	5.4 21	11.6 33	7 22	26.5 33	29.7 34	25.1 27	21.7 12	28.5 29	22.3 5
Segmentation-based matting	27.9	28.8	26.9	28.1	12.8 25	23.5 39	16.6 31	6.6 27	8.3 19	7.3 12	4.8 32	6.1 31	4.3 31	2.1 24	3.9 20	3.1 25	6.7 25	8 10	13.4 29	6 31	8.8 19	8.2 29	31.6 40	35.6 43	38.8 44	24.5 26	32 34	26.7 24
Improved color matting	29	29.1	28.3	29.8	14.9 36	24.5 41	20 42	6.7 29	9.5 27	8.5 28	4.6 19	6.1 32	4.3 32	2.6 38	5.4 30	3.4 36	7.5 32	9.9 26	12.5 24	6 29	10.1 26	8.4 31	26.1 29	26.7 28	23.6 22	23.8 21	25.6 16	26.7 23
Local Spline Regression (LSR)	29.5	31.8	26	30.6	12.2 17	20 25	16.2 27	6.1 19	8.8 23	8.1 21	5.2 38	6.2 34	4.6 35	2.2 32	4.9 27	3.1 29	9.4 42	11.9 36	18.3 40	8.2 39	11.4 30	10.1 37	26.4 31	22.5 15	20.2 14	27 36	26 18	39.8 42
KNN Matting	29.8	31.9	31.3	26.3	16.2 40	19.7 23	16.8 33	8 39	11 36	9 38	4.7 25	6.7 40	4.3 27	3 41	7.7 41	3.7 39	9.2 40	11.3 34	11.3 15	6 30	10.4 27	6.7 17	18.1 3	19.6 6	17 4	27.4 37	41 43	32.7 37
Global Sampling Matting (filter version)	30	27.8	32.4	29.9	12.3 19	24.3 40	16.3 28	7.3 36	10.2 33	9.5 39	5.1 37	6.4 36	4.7 39	2.4 33	4.7 26	3.2 31	5.9 11	9.5 23	12.4 21	6.5 34	13.1 37	8.3 30	26.5 32	28.3 33	30 39	23.6 20	29.1 31	23.5 12
Learning Based Matting	30.8	31.4	29.9	31.1	16 39	22 35	18.7 37	6.6 28	7.4 11	7.4 13	4.8 29	6.1 29	4.3 33	2.1 22	3.7 19	2.8 18	7.5 33	14.5 42	19.5 43	8.6 43	14.1 40	14.6 45	22.5 14	24.8 22	19.9 12	34.6 43	38.5 41	51.2 48
LMSPIR	32	31	33.6	31.5	15.2 38	20 24	19.1 39	6.7 30	11.2 37	8.7 32	4.8 30	5.8 25	4.6 37	2.1 27	6.8 38	3 24	7.9 35	14.3 41	20.2 44	5.5 25	11.4 31	7 21	29.7 38	31 36	29.6 38	24 25	34.2 37	25 17
Shared Matting (Real Time)	32.4	31	33.3	33	12.4 20	21.6 31	16.3 29	9.5 42	13.5 41	9.9 40	4.4 13	5.6 23	4.4 34	2.5 37	6.8 39	3.2 32	7.1 29	10.8 30	12.6 25	5.4 23	9.7 23	7.4 26	35.5 46	35.8 44	35.5 43	27.6 38	33.4 35	29.8 35
Closed-Form Matting	32.8	31.4	30.4	36.8	12.7 23	21.9 34	17.2 35	5.9 16	8.5 21	8.6 31	4.7 26	6 28	4.3 29	2.2 28	4.6 24	3.3 33	9.3 41	12.1 37	19.3 42	8.3 40	14.9 42	13.4 44	34.2 43	32.4 40	27.4 34	26.5 34	25.7 17	48.3 46
Improving Sampling Criterion	36.8	35.8	38.4	36.3	12.7 24	21.1 30	16.4 30	11.5 45	17 46	12.1 45	5.8 44	8.1 46	5.7 44	5.4 49	12.1 48	6.6 48	9.6 44	15.7 43	17.8 38	10.2 45	17 43	11.2 42	23.8 20	26.7 27	25.9 30	22.2 15	27.3 24	23.7 13
Cell-based matting Laplacian	37.1	39.3	35.9	36.3	15.1 37	21.7 32	15.6 22	7.6 37	11.4 38	9 37	5.7 43	6.7 41	5.2 42	3.1 42	6.7 36	4.5 42	8.6 38	11.4 35	14.9 33	8.5 42	13.5 39	11.1 40	27.7 34	26.2 26	27.6 35	32.4 41	37.6 40	37.9 39
Large Kernel Matting	37.3	39.1	36.6	36.3	17.2 41	21.8 33	20.7 43	7.2 35	9.6 31	8.4 26	5.3 39	6.6 39	4.6 36	2.9 40	8.2 43	4.2 40	8.6 39	12.1 38	14.7 32	8 38	13.4 38	11.2 41	33 41	31.8 38	26.1 31	32.1 40	32 33	38.4 41
Robust Matting	38.1	34.3	39	41	17.3 42	28.4 45	21.1 44	10.1 43	16.9 45	11.4 43	4.8 28	6.5 38	5 41	2.8 39	7.3 40	4.4 41	7.3 30	14 40	18.1 39	6.8 35	14.6 41	10.6 39	22.7 15	26.1 25	32.1 41	34.4 42	37 38	38 40
SPS matting	40.1	39.4	43.1	37.8	13.4 29	23 38	14.8 17	12.5 46	18.5 47	12.4 46	6.6 48	9.4 49	6.5 49	4.5 47	12.7 49	5.4 45	9.5 43	16.4 45	18.6 41	9.8 44	18.1 46	10.6 38	26.1 30	30.9 35	26.2 32	25 28	33.5 36	29.5 34
High-res matting	41.2	39.8	42.5	41.4	18.6 44	25.8 42	24.6 46	8.6 40	14.1 42	11.1 42	5 35	6.2 33	4.8 40	2.5 35	8.3 44	3.2 30	7.8 34	14 39	21.4 45	8.5 41	18.1 47	12.2 43	35.3 45	38.1 46	42.6 47	38.7 44	54.6 47	36.8 38
Transfusive Weights	41.5	41.5	41.4	41.8	23.2 46	26.7 44	22.4 45	9.2 41	11.9 40	10.4 41	6.1 46	8.1 45	5.9 46	3.8 45	8 42	5.3 44	12.9 47	21.4 47	37.6 51	13.1 50	22.8 49	18.3 50	20.9 9	22.9 16	19 8	59.5 48	65.7 48	72.8 49
Random Walk Matting	44.9	46.5	42.5	45.8	17.9 43	20.3 26	19.4 40	11.3 44	15.6 43	11.8 44	5.8 45	7 42	6.3 48	3.4 43	6.7 37	4.6 43	13.1 49	22.1 48	27.4 47	12.3 49	18 45	15.7 48	44.1 50	43.5 49	41 46	75.1 49	81.8 50	80.6 50
Geodesic Matting	46.1	47	45.9	45.5	26.9 49	38.5 50	32.5 49	14.2 47	16.5 44	17.4 48	11.7 51	14 52	9.4 51	7.6 51	15.1 50	8.7 51	12.8 46	16.7 46	15.1 34	7.3 37	12.1 34	9.8 36	37.3 48	37.4 45	42.8 48	48.6 47	50 46	48.6 47
Iterative BP Matting	47.2	46.5	47.1	48	23.6 47	29.9 46	27.2 47	16.7 48	24.3 49	20.7 51	6.7 49	9 47	6.3 47	3.8 44	11.3 46	6.8 50	14.1 50	22.8 49	27.9 48	11.4 47	19 48	14.7 46	33.4 42	39.3 47	47.5 51	40.6 45	48.1 45	45.1 44
Easy Matting	47.6	48	47	47.9	23.9 48	32.6 48	30 48	17.1 49	21.8 48	19.4 50	6.3 47	7.5 44	5.8 45	4.7 48	10.5 45	5.6 46	12.1 45	15.7 44	22.9 46	11.2 46	17 44	14.8 47	49.5 51	49.6 51	46.2 50	77.8 50	108.6 52	109.2 51
Improved Bayesian	48.1	48	48.5	47.9	31.2 51	34.9 49	33.9 51	17.8 50	24.4 50	17.2 47	5.5 41	9.3 48	5.3 43	3.9 46	11.4 47	6.6 49	13 48	29.5 50	34.6 50	11.9 48	24.5 50	16.1 49	42.9 49	44.6 50	46 49	92.4 51	46.5 44	45.4 45
Bayesian Matting	49.4	49.5	50.4	48.3	30.3 50	42.4 51	33.4 50	19.2 51	25.8 51	18.4 49	10.8 50	12.4 50	10.8 52	6.6 50	18.5 52	6.2 47	14.2 51	29.8 51	33.2 49	15.4 51	30.6 51	19.7 51	35.8 47	40.6 48	39.6 45	45.3 46	76.8 49	43.6 43
Poisson Matting	51.8	52	51.6	51.8	51.8 52	56.2 52	52 52	28.3 52	43.5 52	30.7 52	12.1 52	13.7 51	9.2 50	11.7 52	18.4 51	11.2 52	22.4 52	36.8 52	55.5 52	21.4 52	32.2 52	22.7 52	53.6 52	72.9 52	58.4 52	125.5 52	84.8 51	139.7 52

Troll - Input image
Drag the window to change the zoom.

References

Method	Reference and notes	Implementation details
Closed-Form Matting	A. Levin, D. Lischinski, Y. Weiss, A Closed Form Solution to Natural Image Matting, CVPR, 2006	Matlab implementation on a Intel Core2 Quad with 2.4 GHZ
Bayesian Matting	Y.Y. Chuang, B. Curless, D. Salesin, R. Szeliski, A Bayesian Approach to Digital Matting, CVPR, 2001	C++ implementation on a Intel Core2 Quad with 2.4 GHZ
Poisson Matting	J. Sun, J. Jia, C.K. Tang, H.Y. Shum, Poisson matting, SIGGRAPH, 2004	Matlab implementation on a Intel Core2 Quad with 2.4 GHZ
Easy Matting	Y. Guan, W. Cheny, X. Liang, Z. Ding, Q. Peng, Easy Matting: A Stroke Based Approach for Continuous Image Matting, Eurographics, 2006	C++ implementation on a Intel Core2 Quad with 2.4 GHZ
Random Walk Matting	L. Grady, T. Schiwietz, S. Aharon, Random Walks For Interactive Alpha-Matting, VIIP, 2005	Matlab/C++ implementation on a Intel Core2 Quad with 2.4 GHZ
Robust Matting	J. Wang, M. Cohen, Optimized Color Sampling for Robust Matting, CVPR, 2007	C++ implementation on a Intel Core2 Quad with 2.4 GHZ
Geodesic Matting	Xue Bai, Guillermo Sapiro, A geodesic framework for fast interactive image and video segmentation and matting, ICCV 2007	C++ implementation on a Intel Core2 Duo with 2.53 GHZ
Iterative BP Matting	Jue Wang, Michael Cohen, Jue Wang and Michael F. Cohen. An iterative optimization approach for unified image segmentation and matting. ICCV 2005.	c++ implementation on a Intel Core2 Quad with 3 GHZ
Improved color matting	C. Rhemann, C. Rother, M. Gelautz, Improving Color Modeling for Alpha Matting. BMVC, 2008	Matlab implementation on a Intel Core2 Duo with 2.4 GHZ
High-res matting	C. Rhemann, C. Rother, A. Rav-Acha, M. Gelautz, T. Sharp, High ResolutionMatting via Interactive Trimap Segmentation. CVPR, 2008	Matlab/C++ implementation on a Intel Core2 Duo with 2.4 GHZ
Large Kernel Matting	Kaiming He, Jian Sun, and Xiaoou Tang, Fast Matting using Large Kernel Matting Laplacian Matrices, CVPR 2010	C++ implementation on a Intel Core Duo with 2 GHZ
Segmentation-based matting	Christoph Rhemann, Carsten Rother, Pushmeet Kohli, Margrit Gelautz, A Spatially Varying PSF-based Prior for Alpha Matting, CVPR 2010	Matlab/C++ implementation on a Intel Core2 Quad with 2.39 GHZ
Shared Matting	Eduardo S. L. Gastal and Manuel M. Oliveira, Shared Sampling for Real-Time Alpha Matting, Eurographics, 2010	C++/GLSL implementation on a Core 2 Quad with 2.8 GHZ
Shared Matting (Real Time)	Eduardo S. L. Gastal and Manuel M. Oliveira, Shared Sampling for Real-Time Alpha Matting, Eurographics, 2010	C++/GLSL implementation on a Core 2 Quad with 2.8 GHZ
Learning Based Matting	Yuanjie Zheng, Chandra Kambhamettu, Yuanjie Zheng, Chandra Kambhamettu. Learning Based Digital Matting. ICCV 2009. SOURE CODE	Matlab/C++ implementation on a Intel Core2 Duo with 2.53 GHZ
LMSPIR	Bei He, Guijin Wang, Zhiwei Ruan, Xuanwu Yin, Xiaokang Pei, Xinggang Lin, Local Matting based on Sample-pair Propagation and Iterative Refinement, ICIP 2012	C++ implementation on a Intel Core2 Dual with 2 GHZ
SVR Matting	Zhanpeng Zhang, Qingsong Zhu, Yaoqin Xie, Learning Based Alpha Matting using Support Vector Regression, ICIP 2012	Matlab implementation on a Intel Pentium Dual-Core with 3 GHZ
Cell-based matting Laplacian	Chen-Yu Tseng and Sheng-Jyh Wang, A cell-based matting Laplacian for contrast enhancement, ICIP 2012	C++ implementation on a Intel Core i3 with 3 GHZ
Global Sampling Matting	Kaiming He, Christoph Rhemann, Carsten Rother, Xiaoou Tang, and Jian Sun, A Global Sampling Method for Alpha Matting, CVPR 2011	C++ implementation on a Intel Core2 with 2 GHZ
Global Sampling Matting (filter version)	Kaiming He, Christoph Rhemann, Carsten Rother, Xiaoou Tang, and Jian Sun, A Global Sampling Method for Alpha Matting, CVPR 2011 (using the guided filter in "Guided Image Filtering", ECCV 2010, by Kaiming He, Jian Sun, and Xiaoou Tang )	C++ implementation on a Intel Core2 with 2 GHZ
Local Spline Regression (LSR)	Shiming Xiang, Feiping Nie, Changshui Zhang, Semi-Supervised Classification via Local Spline Regression. IEEE Transactions on Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence, vol. 32, no. 11, pp. 2039-2053, 2010	C++ implementation on a Intel Core2 with 3 GHZ
Weighted Color and Texture Matting	E.Shahrian and D.Rajan, Weighted Color and Texture Sample Selection for Image Matting , CVPR 2012.	matlab implementation on a Intel(R) Xeon(R) with 2.93 GHZ
KNN Matting	Qifeng Chen, Dingzeyu Li, Chi-Keung Tang, KNN Matting, CVPR 2012	Matlab implementation on a Intel Core 2 Duo with 2.13 GHZ
SRLO Matting	Bei He, Guijin Wang, Xuanwu Yin, Bo Liu, Chenbo Shi, Xinggang Lin, High-accuracy and Quick Matting based on Sample-pair Refinement and Local Optimization, IEICE trans. on Information & Systems, 2013	C++ implementation on a Intel Core2 Dual with 2 GHZ
LNSP Matting	Xiaowu Chen, Dongqing Zou, Ping Tan, Image Matting with Local and Nonlocal Smooth Priors, CVPR 2013	matlab implementation on a intel core2 with 2.2 GHZ
CCM	Yongfang Shi, Au, O.C., Jiahao Pang, Tang, K., Wenxiu Sun, Hong Zhang, Wenjing Zhu, and Luheng Jia, Color Clustering Matting, ICME2013.	Matlab implementation on a Intel Core i7 with 2.8 GHZ
Iterative Transductive Matting	Bei He, Guijin Wang, Chenbo Shi, Xuanwu Yin, Bo Liu, Xinggang Lin, Iterative Transductive Matting, ICIP 2013	Matlab implementation on a Intel Core2 Dual with 2.2 GHZ
Improving Sampling Criterion	Jun Cheng, Zhenjiang Miao, Improving Sampling Criterion for Alpha Matting, RACVPR2013 in Conjunction with ACPR2013	C++ implementation on a Core i5 with 2.5 GHZ
Transfusive Weights	Kaan Yucer, Alexander Sorkine-Hornung, and Olga Sorkine-Hornung, Transfusive Weights for Content-Aware Image Manipulation, VMV2013	Matlab implementation on a Quad-Core Intel Xeon with 3.2 GHZ
Comprehensive sampling	E.Shahrian, D.Rajan, B.Price, S.Cohen, Improving Image Matting using Comprehensive Sampling Sets, CVPR 2013.	Matlab implementation on a Intel Xeon with 2.4 GHZ
Comprehensive Weighted Color and Texture	E.Shahrian , D.Rajan, Weighted Color and Texture Sample Selection for Image Matting, IEEE Transaction on Image Processing , Volume:PP, Issue: 99 , 2013.	Matlab implementation on a Intel i7 with 3.5 GHZ
SPS matting	Ahmad Al-Kabbany and Eric Dubois, "Improved global-sampling matting using sequential pair-selection strategy", In Proc. Visual Information Processing andCommunication V(SPIE), San Francisco, February 2014.	Matlab implementation on a Intel Core2 Quad with 2.66 GHZ
Improved Bayesian	Wenshuang Tan, Automatic Matting of Identification Photos, CAD/Graphics, 2013	C++ implementation on a Intel Core(TM)i7-2600 with 3.4 GHZ
Sparse coded matting	Jubin Johnson, Deepu Rajan, Hisham Cholakkal, Sparse Codes as Alpha Mattes, BMVC 2014.	Matlab implementation on a Intel Xeon with 3.2 GHZ
LNCLM matting	B.-K. Kim, M. Jin, W.-J Song, Local and Nonlocal Color Line Models for Image Matting, IEICE Transactions on Fundamentals of Electronics, Communications and Computer Sciences, vol. E97-A. no.8, pp. 1814-1819, Aug. 2014.	MATLAB implementation on a Intel Core i5-3570 with 3.4 GHZ
Graph-based sparse matting	Jubin Johnson, Ehsan Shahrian Varnousfaderani, Hisham Cholakkal, and Deepu Rajan, Sparse Coding for Alpha Matting, IEEE Transactions on Image Processing, Volume: PP, Issue: 99, 2016.	Matlab implementation on a Intel Xeon with 3.2 GHZ
KL-Divergence Based Sparse Sampling	Levent Karacan, Aykut Erdem and Erkut Erdem, Image Matting with KL-Divergence Based Sparse Sampling,IEEE International Conference on Computer Vision(ICCV) 2015)	Matlab implementation on a Intel� Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 with 2 GHZ
LocalSamplingAndKnnClassification	Xiao Chen, Fazhi He, A Sampling-Propagation Matting Method Based on the Sample Validity and KNN Classification Labeling, Journal of Computer-Aided Design and Computer Graphics (CADCG), vol. 28(12), pp. 2186-2194, 2016.	matlab implementation on a intel i3 2120 with 3.3 GHZ
DCNN Matting	Donghyeon Cho, Yu-Wing Tai, Inso Kweon, Natural Image Matting using Deep Convolutional Neural Networks. ECCV 2016	matlab implementation on a Intel Core i7 with 3.4 GHZ
CSC Matting	Xiaoxue Feng, Xiaohui Liang, Zili Zhang, A Cluster Sampling Method for Image Matting via Sparse Coding. ECCV 2016	Matlab implementation on a Intel(R) Core(TM) i5-3470 with 3.2 GHZ
Patch-based Matting	Guangying Cao, Jianwei Li, Zhiqiang He, Xiaowu Chen, Divide and Conquer: A Self-Adaptive Approach for High-Resolution Image Matting. International Conference on Virtual Reality and Visualization (ICVRV 2016)	matlab implementation on a i7 with 3.6 GHZ
TSPS-RV Matting	Ahmad Al-Kabbany and Eric Dubois, Matting with Sequential Pair Selection Using Graph Transduction. The 21st International Symposium on Vision, Modeling, and Visualization (VMV 2016)	Matlab implementation on a Intel Core2 Quad with 2.66 GHZ
Deep Matting	Ning Xu, Brian Price, Scott Cohen and Thomas Huang, Deep Image Matting, CVPR 2017	Matlab implementation on a I7 with 2.7 GHZ
Information-flow matting	Yagiz Aksoy, Tunc Ozan Aydin and Marc Pollefeys, Designing Effective Inter-Pixel Information Flow for Natural Image Matting, CVPR 2017	Matlab implementation on a Intel Xeon with 3.5 GHZ
ATPM Matting	Xiangyu Zhu, Ping Wang, Zhenghai Huang, Adaptive Propagation Matting Based on Transparency of Image, Multimedia Tools and Applications, 2017 (Online First)	matlab implementation on a Intel Xeon with 2.4 GHZ
Three-layer graph matting	Chao Li, Ping Wang, Xiangyu Zhu, Huali Pi, Three-layer graph framework with the sumD feature for alpha matting. Computer Vision and Image Understanding, vol. 162, pp. 34-45, 2017	c++, octave implementation on a Intel Xeon with 3.2 GHZ
PDMS	Yihui Liang, Pixel-level Discrete Multiobjective Sampling for Alpha Matting, IEEE Transaction on Image Processing, 2017, submitted.	matlab implementation on a Intel i5 2400 with 3.1 GHZ
Three Stages Matting	Xiao Chen, A Three-Stage Matting Method, submitted to MDPI/Applied Sciences, 2017	matlab implementation on a i7 6700k with 4 GHZ
Superpixel-affinity matting	Huali Pi, Submitted to Computer Vision and Image Understanding, 2017	Matlab implementation on a Intel Xeon with 2.4 GHZ
FE2E High-Quality Matting	Anonymous, Learning a Fully End-to-End Convolutional Neural Network for High-Quality Alpha Matting, anonymous CVPR 2019 submission 542	Matlab/C++ implementation implementation on a Intel(R) Xeon(R) with 2.2 GHZ
AlphaGAN	Sebastian Lutz, Konstantinos Amplianitis, Aljosa Smolic, AlphaGAN: Generative Adversarial Networks for Natural Image Matting, BMVC 2018	Python implementation on a Intel i7-6700 with 3.4 GHZ
SampleNet Matting	anonymous, Learning-based Sampling for Natural Image Matting, CVPR 2019 submission #1358	Python implementation on a Intel Core i7-7700K with 4.7 GHZ